Ethics Theory, TLP-UPSC Mains Answer Writing
Q. 4. “Regional aspirations in India often emerge from a perceived denial of cultural identity, autonomy, and development. Critically examine the factors fueling regionalism in contemporary India and suggest balanced approaches to address them.” (250 words, 15 marks)
Introduction
Historian Bipan Chandra defined regionalism as an expression of group identity based on culture, language, or territory. In India, it emerges when regions feel denied fair development, representation, or recognition in the national mainstream.
Body
Factors Fueling Regionalism in Contemporary India
- Perceived Economic Disparities: Unequal development among states fuels resentment and demands for special status. Example: Backward regions like Vidarbha and Bundelkhand cite poor infrastructure and economic neglect as reasons for separate statehood.
- Assertion of Cultural and Linguistic Identity: Communities resist perceived cultural homogenization. Example: Protests in Tamil Nadu against the imposition of Hindi and for Tamil pride reflect deep-rooted linguistic regionalism.
- Demand for Political Autonomy: Ethnic and tribal groups seek greater administrative control. Example: Gorkhaland and Bodoland movements stem from a desire for self-governance and local representation.
- Migration and Demographic Changes: Influx of migrants causes fear of cultural dilution and economic competition. Example: Movements in Assam and Meghalaya against “outsiders” are driven by anxieties over identity and resources.
- Historical Neglect and Identity-Based Mobilisation: Legacy of colonial boundaries and post-independence neglect fuels sentiments. Example: Telangana statehood movement was rooted in historical neglect by the Andhra region post-merger in 1956.
Balanced Approaches to Address Regional Aspirations
- Strengthening Cooperative Federalism: Promote dialogue and equitable resource sharing between Centre and States. Example: Use of Inter-State Council and NITI Aayog to address regional concerns collaboratively.
- Inclusive Development Policies: Target backward regions with special packages and decentralised planning. Example: Aspirational Districts Programme aims at balanced development across lagging districts.
- Cultural Recognition and Promotion: Protect and celebrate regional languages, festivals, and heritage through official platforms. Example: Inclusion of regional languages in education and public services strengthens cultural pride.
- Responsive Political Representation: Empower local governance and ensure regional voices in decision-making. Example: Formation of autonomous councils under the Sixth Schedule in Northeast India has helped address tribal aspirations.
- Strengthening Fiscal Federalism: Ensure fair devolution of funds through Finance Commissions. Example: Timely transfers and special grants to lagging states help reduce economic imbalances.
- Transparent Grievance Redressal: Establish credible mechanisms to address regional demands democratically. Example: Addressing issues through commissions and consultative bodies builds trust and avoids conflict escalation.
Conclusion
While regionalism poses challenges, it also reflects India’s pluralist strength. As Rajni Kothari said, “India is a country held together by political and cultural diversities.” Acknowledging and accommodating these diversities is key to ensuring national unity and democratic vitality.