Ethics Theory, TLP-UPSC Mains Answer Writing
Q. 12. How have caste-based reservations affected the socio-economic progress of marginalised communities in India? Do they also lead to increased caste pride and awareness? What were B.R. Ambedkar’s suggestions to annihilate the caste system? (250 words, 15 marks)
Introduction
Caste-based reservations were introduced as a form of affirmative action to correct historical injustices and ensure social justice for SCs, STs, and OBCs. While they have promoted mobility, exclusion, identity assertion, and caste prejudice still persist.
Body
Socio-Economic Impact of Caste-Based Reservations
- Educational Mobility: Increased access to schools, colleges, and scholarships for SC/ST/OBC students, e.g., SC enrolment in higher education rose to 15.6% (AISHE 2020–21).
- Employment Inclusion: Representation in public services, particularly in Group C & D jobs, has improved basic livelihood security.
- Political Empowerment: Reservation in Panchayats and Lok Sabha has enabled grassroots leadership from marginalised communities.
- Creation of Middle Class: Emergence of a Dalit-OBC middle class in urban India through jobs and education.
- Persistent Gaps: Despite benefits, economic inequality within castes and discrimination in private sector remain unaddressed.
- These outcomes have not only improved material conditions for many but also sparked a stronger assertion of caste identity and dignity among marginalised groups.
Rise in Caste Pride and Awareness
- Identity Assertion: Movements like Dalit Panthers, BSP, and Jatav mobilisation reflect rising caste pride and political consciousness.
- Cultural Renaissance: Celebration of figures like Ambedkar, Periyar, Phule in community festivals and symbols.
- Social Assertion: Visible shift from silent suffering to demand for dignity and equality.
B.R. Ambedkar’s Ideas to Annihilate Caste
- Inter-caste Marriage: Urged caste Hindus to marry outside their jati to break endogamy and social separation.
- Abolition of Varna System: Rejected religious justification for caste; emphasised constitutional morality over Manusmriti.
- Education and Representation: Believed in educate, agitate, organise as tools for Dalit empowerment.
- Separate Identity: Advocated for separate electorates (initially) and later conversion to Buddhism to escape Hindu caste structure.
- State Intervention: Called for reservations, legal safeguards, and land reforms to dismantle caste-based exclusion.
Conclusion
Ambedkar stressed equality through rights, while Gandhi called for social harmony. Together, their visions remind us that true progress needs both justice and unity to ensure equal opportunity and dignity for all in Indian society.
