Ethics Theory, TLP-UPSC Mains Answer Writing
Q. 3. “Urbanisation in India has often overlooked the needs of the poor. Examine the key challenges faced by the urban poor and suggest practical solutions for inclusive urban development.” (150 words, 10 marks)
Introduction
India is urbanising rapidly, with over 35% of the population now living in cities. However, this growth has been uneven, often marginalising the urban poor in terms of housing, services, and opportunities—threatening the goal of inclusive urbanisation.
Body
Challenges Faced by the Urban Poor
- Inadequate Housing: Most urban poor live in slums or informal settlements with poor infrastructure and insecurity of tenure. Example: Over 65 million people live in slums, as per the 2011 Census.
- Lack of Basic Services: Access to clean water, sanitation, electricity, and waste disposal is limited or absent in many poor urban areas. Example: National Family Health Survey-5 shows urban poor have lower access to piped water than the urban average.
- Informal Employment and Low Wages: A large portion of the urban poor work in informal jobs with no social security or legal protection. Example: Periodic Labour Force Survey (2022) shows over 70% of urban workers are informally employed.
- Health Vulnerabilities: Poor living conditions and lack of health facilities make them prone to communicable and lifestyle diseases. Example: COVID-19 disproportionately affected urban slums due to cramped spaces and poor hygiene.
- Educational Disparities: Children from poor urban families often drop out or study in under-resourced schools. Example: ASER reports show large learning gaps between children in slums and those in formal housing.
- Risk of Displacement: Slum demolitions and redevelopment often exclude or displace the poor without proper rehabilitation. Example: Delhi’s Yamuna floodplain evictions in 2023 left hundreds without shelter or relocation.
Inclusive Urban Development: Practical Solutions
- Affordable Housing Schemes: Expand rental housing and upgrade existing slums under PMAY-U with participatory planning.
- Urban Employment Guarantee: Implement schemes like MGNREGA for urban areas to provide work and income stability.
- Inclusive Public Services: Ensure last-mile access to water, sanitation, healthcare, and education through urban local bodies.
- Legal Recognition and Tenure Security: Provide property rights or occupancy certificates to slum dwellers to avoid forced evictions.
- Skill Development and Formalisation: Link urban poor to skill centres and facilitate transition to formal sector jobs under Deendayal Antyodaya Yojana.
- Strengthen Local Governance: Empower municipalities with funds and community engagement tools for pro-poor city planning.
Conclusion
Inclusive urbanisation is key to a just and sustainable India. As per NITI Aayog’s Urban Planning Report (2021), empowering local bodies, expanding housing, and ensuring services for all can make cities more equitable and future-ready.