For Previous TLP (ARCHIVES) – CLICK HERE

 

SYNOPSIS [29th JUNE,2021] Day 122: IASbaba’s TLP (Phase 1): UPSC Mains Answer Writing (General Studies)

 

1. “The conditions which necessitated the formulation and adoption of CSS don’t exist anymore”. Comment. Also discuss the factors that led to failure/ limited success of CSS. What modifications would you suggest for making CSS more result oriented?

Approach 

Candidates can directly start with giving background of the CSS. And then properly write about working of CSS, in later part address the gaps/failures in its implementation, before conclusion suggestions measures to improve and increase efficiency of CSS can be written.

Introduction

Centrally sponsored schemes have their origins immediately after independence where India was weak and underdeveloped .The states had limited expertise and resources to achieve over all National objectives such as family planning and hence intervention of centre was required. 

Body

What is CSS?

But the CSS have had limited success due to gaps at formulation and implementation stages such as

Some measures to improve efficiency and effectiveness of CSS are

Conclusion

Since the schemes are implemented by states, they should have substantial flexibility to ensure that the schemes benefit the targeted groups. Restructuring of the CSS which will entail constitutional amendment in Seventh Schedule should be done after thorough deliberations with all stakeholders. This revision should not be done without consultation with states, Interstate Council can be the ideal platform to discuss these issues.


2. Write a critical note on the nature of relationship within federal framework between Delhi state and the Union government. (200 Words, 10 Marks).

Approach 

As question demands critical note on the nature of relationship of Delhi government and union government candidates need to highlight the legal and political controversies involved. Then suggest few measures to overcome the shortcomings in federal framework.

Introduction 

Delhi was given a fully elected legislative assembly and a responsible government through an amendment in the constitution in 1991. Though technically a Union Territory, Delhi was treated as a special case, being the capital of the country, and given a special constitutional status by parliament in exercise of its constituent power as against its normal legislative power.

Body 

Nature of Relationship Between Delhi and Union government:

Many constitutional experts are of the view that the recently proposed bill is the very antithesis of what the Court has said. They held that the Bill, if it becomes law, will wholly undermine the Court’s efforts to strengthen the elected government vis-à-vis the appointed Lieutenant Governor.

Way forward:

Conclusion

The Supreme Court, in the NCT Delhi case, rightly employed a purposive interpretation of the Constitution to hold that since representative government is a basic feature of the Constitution, the elected government must have primacy. A mature discussion between stakeholders that looks beyond short-term political gains holds the potential to resolve the embedded contradiction.


3. Critically examine the impact of coalition-politics on the Indian Political System. Make a case on the need for cooperative federalism in today’s world.

Approach

Candidates need to critically examine the impact of coalition politics by giving both side of arguments. And as question demands highlight on relevance of the cooperatives federalism in todays political system.

Introduction 

The slow decline of national parties and emergence of regional parties led to the evolution of coalition politics in India. Its influence on Indian Political System is one of degree than of kind. 1960’s saw several regional movement centred upon the regional issues. This led to emergence of multiple political parties successfully contesting assembly elections based on regional issues.

Body

Impact of coalition politics:

Coalition government threw its own challenges of like unstable governments, emergence of culture of defections, increased conflict between Centre and State etc:

Coopertive federalism is a step forward where states can play crucial role in national planning:

Conclusion

Cooperation plays a crucial role in dealing with many economic and social policies. Cooperative federalism alone strengthens the nation from within by enabling it to withstand adversities and challenges because of its inherent resilience and malleability. Thus efforts must be made towards cooperative federalism.

TLP Synopsis Day 122 PDF

Search now.....

Sign Up To Receive Regular Updates